Top line accelerating.
+4.3% YoY versus −3.4% prior. 3y CAGR +4.4%.
+4.3%We use cookies
MainRatios uses cookies for essential site functions. With your consent, we also use analytics cookies including session replay sampling (PostHog, Google Analytics) and advertising cookies (Google AdSense). You can reject non-essential cookies, including the "sale" or sharing of personal information under CCPA, and you may withdraw consent at any time (GDPR). See our Privacy Policy for details.
Industrials · Market Cap: $419.4B
Fundamentals as of 2025-12-31
All analysis on this page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Fair values are model-based estimates. Always do your own research.
The Question
1 of 2 legendary models say AVOID CAT — but Warren Buffett disagrees.
What would legendary investors pay for CAT?
These figures are not quotes or opinions from Buffett, Graham, Lynch or the other investors. They are our own estimates, computed by applying the intrinsic-value formulas each investor is known for to this company’s financials.
For educational purposes only. Not a recommendation to buy or sell securities.
Mixed — Caterpillar Inc. has 41.6% ROE but D/E 3.62.
Financial story
Mixed — Caterpillar Inc.'s 41.6% ROE is strong, but its 3.62 debt-to-equity is elevated.
Bottom line: CAT is rated BUY by 1 of 2 legendary models, with 1 holding and 0 flagging it overvalued, but earns a C sector grade (50/100) in Industrials. Whether the premium is justified depends on which lens you trust. Drill into the valuation breakdown and sector ranking for the full picture.
Strength. Caterpillar quietly became an AI-power supplier: power-generation sales to data-center customers jumped ~48% last quarter and total backlog hit a record $63 billion (+79%), the kind of multi-year visibility a late-cycle machinery maker almost never shows. Why the market now pays ~45× earnings for yellow iron — roughly double its 20-year average — is the number this note pulls apart.
Risk. At ~45× earnings — nearly double its two-decade average — the price already assumes the data-center power boom is permanent, even as the cyclical legs wobble: Resource Industries profit fell 39% last quarter and consensus sees barely ~3% upside from here. What the multiple leaves open isn't whether Caterpillar delivers — it's what happens to the re-rating if that demand turns out to be cyclical.
How does CAT compare?
Caterpillar trades near 45× trailing earnings at ~$911 (and ~49× near its recent high) because the market has stopped pricing it as a machinery cyclical and started pricing it as a data-center power supplier. That multiple is almost double its 20-year average near 21×. The re-rating rests on the Power & Energy segment, where power-generation sales to data centers grew about 48% last quarter and total backlog hit a record $63 billion, up 79% in a year — visibility the market is capitalizing as recurring growth rather than a cyclical peak.
Caterpillar's Power & Energy segment (formerly Energy & Transportation) sells the large engines and gas turbines that generate electricity on site, and hyperscale data centers are buying them to get gigawatts of power years before the grid can connect them. In Q1 2026 power-generation sales to end users grew about 48% and oil-and-gas demand rose 16%. The large reciprocating-engine backlog has grown more than 3.5× since early 2024, and the company raised its 2030 target so power-generation sales run more than triple the 2024 baseline.
In the first quarter of 2026 Caterpillar reported $17.4 billion of revenue, up 22% year over year, and GAAP diluted EPS of $5.47, up about 30%; the adjusted figure was $5.54, though roughly $0.46 of that came from non-operational items. Power & Energy sales rose 22% and Construction Industries 38%, while Resource Industries profit fell 39% on tariff costs. The company also returned $5.7 billion to shareholders through buybacks and dividends in the quarter and lifted its full-year outlook.
By its own history, Caterpillar's ~45× trailing multiple is rich: it is nearly double its 20-year average near 21× and well above peers like Deere (~31× forward) and Cummins (~23×). Analyst consensus frames little room — a 12-month target around $940, only ~3% above the ~$911 price, with a very wide $575–$1,165 spread. The premium reflects the data-center power story and a record $63 billion backlog; what it leaves thin is any margin of safety if that multiple reverts toward its cyclical norm.
Caterpillar's total backlog reached a record $63 billion in Q1 2026, up about $28 billion — or 79% — from a year earlier, driven largely by data-center power orders. Its large reciprocating-engine backlog has grown more than 3.5 times since the start of 2024, and capacity is sold out years ahead, stretching past 2027. The company is expanding large-engine capacity from roughly twice 2024 levels toward three times, and in April agreed to supply about two gigawatts of gas gensets to American Intelligence & Power for hyperscale AI infrastructure.
The single biggest risk is the valuation itself: at ~45× earnings the stock is priced for the data-center power boom to be permanent, so a de-rating toward its ~21× norm could weigh on returns even if the business holds. The cyclical legs are already softening — Resource Industries profit fell 39%, and Construction's +38% sales were flattered by a ~$1.5 billion dealer build (users up just 7%). Tariffs add a guided $2.2–$2.4 billion cost in 2026, and consensus sees only ~3% upside from here.
+4.3% YoY versus −3.4% prior. 3y CAGR +4.4%.
+4.3%Net margin 13.1% versus 16.7% prior (−3.5pp). Operating 16.6%.
13.1%P/E 45.0x — 154% above the 5y median of 17.7x. Forward 40.0x hints at EPS expansion next year.
45.0xSee exactly where CAT ranks
Sign in to unlock the full sector ranking — free.
Sign in to see the rankingCAT sits at #82 in Industrials with a C grade (50/100).
| Firm | Target | Upside | vs. price | Rating | Recent move | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
JP JPMorgan Tami Zakaria | $1165 | +18% | Overweight | raised 1125→1165 (street high) | Jun 17 | |
EI Evercore ISI | $1103 |

| +12% |
| Outperform |
| reiterated |
| May 11 |
JE Jefferies | $1045 | +6% | Buy | raised 900→1045 | May 1 |
TR Truist Jamie Cook | $1043 | +6% | — | set target | May 1 |
AR Argus John Eade | $990 | +0% | Buy | raised 820→990 | May 5 |
MS Morgan Stanley Angel Castillo | $915 | −7% | Equal Weight | upgraded from Underweight, doubled 430→915 | May 1 |
UG UBS Group | $900 | −9% | Neutral | reiterated | Jun 2 |
DD DA Davidson Michael Shlisky | $845 | −14% | Neutral | raised 650→845 | May 4 |
![]() Barclays Adam Seiden | $800 | −19% | Equal Weight | raised 700→800 | May 1 |